Book Appointment Now

Why Series LLCs Have Serious Problems For Asset Protection

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Why Series LLCs Have Serious Problems For Asset Protection

There has been much debate about whether series LLCs are a viable asset protection tool. If you are asking yourself, “Is a series LLC a good idea?” then here is the answer: No, they are not a good idea, and they should not be part of your asset protection plan. Why? 

Because the series LLC has not been tested or been successful in a court of law. When it comes to protecting your assets from a lawsuit, certainty in litigation is extremely important. As any litigation attorney will tell you, a judge has a great deal of discretion.  However, using a risky unproven tool to prevent a plaintiff from seizing your asset is unwise.

Overview of the LLC and When It Should Be Utilized

By way of background, the use of a limited liability company (LLC) is recommended in many different instances.  An LLC is a very versatile tool.  And like all tools, it requires great skill to know how to use it well for asset protection purposes. 

For example, LLCs often work well as a method of protecting high value assets such as real estate, equipment, intellectual property (such as a patent) and liquid assets (i.e. brokerage accounts, crypto, precious metals, art, jewelry and other collections). If you own commercial or rental property, it’s important that you hold title to that property in an entity. If this entity (most likely an LLC) is run and managed properly, it can protect you from any personal liability and protect the investment property from your personal lawsuits. 

However, the series LLC may not offer the same level of legal protection and may actually present significant legal risk. 

Structure of a Series LLC 

The general structure of a series LLC is predicated on laws in certain states (a minority of states, not a majority) allowing someone to create a separate series within a single LLC. This would allow for a separate series of interests, members and managers, providing separate duties, powers and rights, including the rights to profits and losses with respect to specific property and obligations.

In states with series LLC statutes on the books, each series within the LLC can work as a separate entity under state law. This is why some people promote the series LLC as a viable asset protection tool. In theory, they would provide the flexibility to shield property in different series from liabilities incurred in or against one another without paying state fees for multiple entities. For example, the owner of two properties operating under an LLC could choose to place each into a separate series, so that liabilities from one would not cause problems with the assets of the other.

Why Series LLCs Should Be Avoided

There are many drawbacks associated with using a Series LLC for asset protection. Conceptually, the Series LLC does not make much sense. Even in Series LLC states, it would not be recommended to use this structure for asset protection. For example, if someone forms an LLC entity and it is sued, all of the assets within that entity are exposed, regardless of whether they are in separate series. Furthermore, there is no court case substantiating or validating the extension of asset protection to assets held in a Series LLC. Other reasons the Series LLC should be avoided include: 

Legal Uncertainty Associated with the Series LLC

One of the biggest issues with the series LLC, and a major reason why it should be avoided, is that many states do not have series LLC legislation. As a result, states without a series LLC statute on the books could opt to ignore the laws of the state where the series LLC was created thereby exposing yourself to significant potential legal risk and liability. 

Series LLCs Can Be Costly to Establish

People mistakenly believe that setting up a series LLC offers cost savings relative to establishing multiple separate LLCs. However, this is not accurate. In fact, it is generally more complicated and more expensive to establish a series LLC. 

Difficulties with Series LLCs Across State Lines

If someone establishes a series LLC in Nevada, then registers it as a foreign entity conducting business in the state of Arizona, each series in the LLC owns a separate piece of property. If there’s a lawsuit regarding one of these properties, there is uncertainty as to whether an Arizona court would recognize the series structure of the LLC, including application of Nevada law to the real estate and activities in Arizona. 

The American Bar Association (ABA) Declined to Endorse the Series LLC Concept

The ABA’s National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws conducted an intensive, multi-year review of the Series LLCs and declined to endorse their usage. The ABA committee raised concerns about the multitude of series LLC risks, including whether the alleged “internal liability shield” promoted by series LLC proponents would be recognized in non-series LLC states. Other concerns included whether bankruptcy would consolidate all of the series LLC into the parent and the general drafting and record keeping complexities associated with the series LLC. Ultimately, the ABA committee declined to embrace or formally adopt the series LLC concept.

Limited Number of Series LLC States

As mentioned, a notable drawback to using a series LLC for asset protection is the fact that the series LLC is not available in all states. In fact, the series LLC has only been adopted in the following states: Delaware, Nevada, Illinois, Iowa, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Texas and Utah.

Wyoming Does Not Recognize Series LLCs

The state most notably missing from the list above is Wyoming.  Wyoming LLCs have the strongest protection against plaintiffs.  Creating a holding company LLC in a state outside of Wyoming is not ideal due to the lack of other state’s creditor protections.

Have Questions About Series LLC Risks? Contact Ultimate Asset Protection

If you are asking yourself, “Is a Series LLC a good idea?” then you need to contact Ultimate Asset Protection today. 

Our team stands ready to offer effective and accurate guidance on different asset protection strategies. We can also help develop custom-tailored asset protection solutions to protect your hard-earned wealth. 

The Ultimate Asset Protection firm, led by attorney John Skabelund, collaborates with clients to craft bespoke asset protection plans designed to reduce liability and exposure and provide security to your family’s financial legacy. 
Contact us today to learn more.

You may Also be interested in:

A Quick Guide to Domestic Asset Protection Trusts (DAPTs)

If you have significant assets and are looking for ways to protect your hard-earned wealth from exposure to creditors or legal claims, there are various legal options to consider, including establishing a Domestic Asset Protection Trust (DAPT). At its core, DAPTs enable individuals to transfer assets into an irrevocable trust while still retaining some control […]

View Post

Corporate Transparency Act 101

The Corporate Transparency Act (CTA), which went into effect on January 1, 2024, requires entities within its scope to disclose information, including information regarding beneficial owners, to the United States Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (also known as “FinCEN”). Enacted as part of the Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020, the CTA requires covered entities […]

View Post

John Skabelund’s Interview with Wealth Formula

Attorney John Skabelund describes the difference between estate planning and asset protection, the necessity of both, and how they work together in this Wealth Formula podcast. Listen here

View Post

Ready to start your consultation?

Skabelund isn’t just there to draft the estate plan. As important as that is, we know that life changes, goals evolve, and the estate and business plan must adjust appropriately.

We meet with our clients on an annual basis and offer a subscription program for those who would benefit from even more frequent counsel. We’re there for clients in the event litigation arises. We’re with you for the long haul.

Book Appointment Now